Annuity strategies
Annuities are contracts, not investments, and the category covers products with almost nothing in common. Understanding which type is being discussed is the first step.
The problem
Few financial products generate stronger opinions with less precision. Annuities are described as either indispensable or indefensible, usually without specifying which kind is meant.
In practice an annuity is a contract with an insurance company. What that contract does depends entirely on its type and terms. A single premium immediate annuity and a variable annuity with living benefit riders share a category name and very little else.
The main categories
| Type | Designed to do | Principal limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Single premium immediate annuity | Convert a lump sum into income beginning now | Illiquid once annuitized, terms fixed, inflation exposure unless a rider is added |
| Deferred income annuity | Convert a lump sum into income starting at a future date | Long deferral with limited access, purchasing power risk |
| Multi year guaranteed annuity | Provide a stated interest rate for a set term | Surrender charges, rate fixed for the term, taxed as ordinary income on withdrawal |
| Fixed indexed annuity | Credit interest tied to an index with protection against index losses | Caps, spreads or participation rates limit credited interest, surrender periods, rider fees |
| Variable annuity | Provide market participation inside an insurance contract, often with optional guarantees | Investment risk, layered fees, complexity, guarantees carry additional cost |
When an annuity is a poor fit
- When the funds may be needed during the surrender period.
- When the objective is maximum growth rather than defined income or downside protection.
- When the contract's costs are not clearly understood and quantified.
- When existing guaranteed income already covers essential spending.
- When the purchase would concentrate too much of a portfolio with one issuing company.
Questions to ask about any annuity presented to you
- Exactly which type of annuity is this
- What are all the fees, including rider charges, and what are they in dollars per year
- What is the surrender schedule and what does year one access cost
- If it is indexed, what are the caps, spreads or participation rates, and can the company change them
- What is guaranteed contractually versus illustrated as a possibility
- What is the financial strength rating of the issuing company
- How is the person recommending this compensated
Key takeaways
- Annuity is a category, not a product. Specificity is essential.
- Guarantees are obligations of the issuing insurance company only.
- Illustrated values are not guaranteed values.
- Liquidity given up is the most commonly underestimated cost.
Important disclosure
This page is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice, and not a recommendation of any specific product. Suitability depends on individual facts, product terms, issuing company strength and current law. Guarantees, where mentioned, are backed solely by the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Consult your own licensed legal and tax professionals before acting.
Last reviewed 2026-08-09 by Tim Parnell.
Related
Retirement income
How retirement income planning differs from accumulation, including sequence risk, income sources, tax character and the tradeoffs of each approach.
Fixed indexed annuity vs variable annuity
How fixed indexed and variable annuities differ in risk, cost, upside and complexity, and where each may or may not fit.
Retirees and near retirees
Planning for the shift from accumulation to distribution, including sequence risk, income structure, tax sequencing and long term care exposure.
Glossary
Plain language definitions of the retirement income, insurance, tax and business exit terms used throughout Legacy Wealth Nation.